How I Chose the 100 Best American Movies of the 20th Century
Part 1 (1917–1939) | Complete 100-Film List
Most “best movies” lists just lean on awards, critics, and reputation. Those things matter, but they don’t really tell you if a movie is worth watching tonight. That’s why I made this list with one main rule: any film here should be enjoyable for a typical 25-year-old with no nostalgia or special forgiveness for older movies, and every pick still needs a real claim to greatness.
This is not a list of the greatest movies ever made, and it’s not just my personal favorites; it’s where those two groups meet. I’ve watched thousands of films over 40 years, seen every movie on this list, and compared them extensively. Here are the rules I used:
Two tests, no free passes
Every film had to prove itself in two separate ways, and doing well in one area doesn’t make up for falling short in the other. If a classic doesn’t work for a new viewer, or a popular movie isn’t deep enough to stand with the best, it’s out.
1. Durability: the no-homework rule
Would someone in their 20s or 30s, watching for the first time, without any film-history background or extra patience for old movies, actually enjoy it?
Quiet, tragic, slow-paced, or ambiguous films are welcome, as long as the suspense, humor, or emotional payoff is worth it. An unhappy ending is fine, a film only fails if its drawbacks outweigh what you get in return.
2. Significance: a real reason to be included
Is there a strong reason this film should be one of just 100 American movies? That could mean it broke new ground, had a lasting influence, set a high standard for acting or craft, or is simply a great story. It doesn’t need to have changed cinema.
No nostalgia, no historical obligation
No movie gets a spot just for being early, famous, winning awards, or being loved by critics. A silent film isn’t included just because it was first, and a classic doesn’t stay just because it’s been praised for years. I didn’t give extra points to newer films either, the only question is whether it still feels rewarding to watch.
That’s why I use a first-time viewer in their 20s or 30s as my test. People who grew up with these movies (like me) have affection and familiarity, which are great reasons to love a film, but that’s not what I wanted to capture.
How I made my choices
My own judgment is the main factor, about 90%. I use critics and audience opinions as a check to see if strengths or weaknesses are widely shared, but not as a vote. Technical skill, production size, and awards only matter if they create something you actually feel: suspense, laughter, emotion, or atmosphere. Just being well-made isn’t enough.
The ground rules
- Only American films count. The main production company or studio has to be American, with most of the funding from the US. Where it was filmed doesn’t matter that much, so a Hollywood movie shot overseas is fine, but a foreign film with some American money or distribution doesn’t. That rule forced very painful cuts, including Lawrence of Arabia, one of my three favorite movies ever, and The African Queen.
- Films must be from 1900 to 1999 and at least 61 minutes long. That’s why the two short films at the start of Part 1 are just bonus warm-ups, not official entries.
- The film must be complete and viewable as intended. Lost or incomplete films are excluded unless there’s a full or nearly full restoration.
- There are no quotas for each decade. Some years produced many lasting films, and the list reflects that rather than spreading my picks evenly.
The content rule
A film is excluded if it promotes cruelty, dehumanization, political repression, or if its emotional payoff depends on celebrating that cruelty. Movies with strong political arguments are fine, and so are films that show a character’s racism from a critical distance, and old-fashioned attitudes that aren’t central to the story don’t disqualify a film. The key is whether the movie asks you to think about something, or if it wants you to agree with it.
Exactly 100 films in order, not ranked
The final list has exactly 100 feature films. Passing both tests makes a movie a strong candidate, but not a guaranteed pick. Once I had 100, a new film could only get in by making a stronger case than one already on the list, and nothing stays just because of reputation.
The films are listed in chronological order, partly because I think ranking is stupid, and partly because listing them by year also lets you see how American cinema changed over time. Feel free to start anywhere.
This isn’t the only possible list of 100, and it’s normal for people to disagree with some of my choices. That’s a good thing, let me know which films you would change and why. I wasn’t aiming for a list everyone would agree on: I wanted 100 movies I can confidently recommend to someone who just wants to watch something great.
Ready to watch? Check out the full list in The 100 Best American Movies of the 20th Century, or start with Classic Movies Worth Watching Part 1.