Religious Freedom: A Constitutional Right Under Threat

Religious Freedom: A Constitutional Right Under Threat

“You can believe it, just don’t bring it here.”

What is religious freedom? It is freedom of worship in all its forms: freedom of assembly, freedom of speech, freedom to act on personal beliefs, and freedom for others to do the same. Religious freedom allows each of us to decide for ourselves what we believe, how we live and act according to our faith. Is our religious freedom under threat?

In 2026, Sarianne Beronja sent in a Bible verse for her Wisconsin high school’s graduation slideshow, but the administrators said no. She tried again, this time writing in her own words: “All thanks to God for being beside me through these last four years.” The school rejected that, too.

No one was asked to bow their head, recite a creed, or even agree with her, and other students could share personal messages that weren’t religious; she only wanted to express what helped her through high school. It took a lawyer’s letter and the threat of a lawsuit before the district apologized for not applying its rules fairly, agreed to First Amendment training, and settled for $12,500. After that it stopped accepting written student messages for graduation slideshows altogether.

If you have to threaten to sue to use a right, then that right is under threat. The First Amendment protects your ability to live out your faith in public life, not just keep it private. Still, schools, employers and local governments often treat faith as something you should leave outside. Governments often restrict religion in the name of keeping the peace, but in a study of nearly 200 countries, researchers found that heavier government regulation of religion went hand in hand with more persecution, not less.

The two guarantees in the Bill of Rights

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” These are the first words of the First Amendment. The first part stops the government from establishing or favoring religion. The second part protects people’s freedom to practice their faith. Both limit what the government can do. Neither tells citizens to keep their faith private.

Pay attention to the word “exercise.” Religious freedom is much more than choosing what you believe; it also means you can worship, gather, speak, and act on your beliefs. You have the right to decide for yourself what God expects of you, and to give that same freedom to people who believe differently or don’t believe in God at all.

Think about the difference between a school telling students to pray and a student choosing to thank God. When the school tells students to pray, it uses its authority. When a student thanks God, she is speaking for herself. The Department of Education’s 2026 guidance is very clear: a valedictorian who wants to thank God in her graduation speech should be allowed to do so, because letting her speak doesn’t mean the school is endorsing her words.

Boston made a similar mistake outside of a school setting. The city had approved 284 flag-raising ceremonies at City Hall but rejected a Christian flag because it was religious. The Supreme Court unanimously decided that Boston had opened the program to private speakers and could not exclude a religious viewpoint. The city did not have to endorse the flag, but it had to stop using religion as a reason to exclude private speakers.

What the threat looks like up close

In the past twenty years, restrictions have often taken the form of conditional freedom: keep your job, your contract, or your place in a public program only if you set aside a religious practice. Abercrombie & Fitch did not hire a Muslim applicant because it did not want to accommodate her headscarf. Philadelphia stopped sending children to Catholic Social Services because of its policy on certifying same-sex couples, even though other agencies offered certification, no same-sex couple had asked Catholic Social Services, and the city could make exceptions. Both cases went to the Supreme Court.

A Christian student group in San Jose, CA, welcomed students to join but required its leaders to agree with the group’s beliefs, so the district withdrew its recognition of the group. Later, a federal appeals court granted preliminary relief, saying that the district allowed other student groups to use selective criteria but didn’t give the same freedom to the Christian group. The issue wasn’t whether a club could set any rule, but why this club couldn’t choose leaders who supported its mission when other clubs could.

This pressure affects worship itself. During the COVID pandemic New York limited religious services to 10 or 25 people in some zones, while a lot of businesses did not have similar limits. Catholic and Orthodox Jewish groups got emergency relief. For congregations looking for a place to meet, zoning can be a big hurdle. By March 2024, the Justice Department had started more than 155 formal religious land-use investigations and filed almost 30 lawsuits since 2000. In one review, the DOJ found positive outcomes without lawsuits in 84% of non-Muslim cases but only 20% of cases involving mosques or Islamic schools.

Even when a congregation has a place to worship, people might still be afraid to go. In 2025, the federal government took back guidance that had limited immigration enforcement in or near houses of worship. Congregations said it kept people from attending services and made ministry harder; some groups got temporary court protection, but this didn’t bring back the safeguard for everyone.

In prison, even basic religious practices can depend on what the institution allows. In 2025, the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights found that people in prison, especially those from minority faiths, still did not get enough accommodations and had trouble getting their complaints heard, almost twenty years after the commission’s earlier review.

Then there is Oak Flat. In 2025, the Supreme Court chose not to hear Apache Stronghold’s challenge to a federal land transfer for a copper mine. This project threatens a sacred site in Arizona where Apache people have held religious ceremonies for generations. A congregation might find another building, but there is no other Oak Flat.

When hostility becomes threatening

Not wanting to hear about religion is not the same thing as making people fear for their safety. Law enforcement recorded 1,014 hate crimes based on religion in 2014 and 2,783 in 2024. These are reported numbers, and changes in reporting and agency participation make it hard to know how much actual crime increased, but the threat is real: most of the 2024 incidents targeted Jewish people, and the FBI found more threats against Jewish and Muslim people and institutions. For someone deciding if it’s safe to attend worship, the issue is not whether their beliefs are welcome in conversation. It’s whether they can gather without fear.

When officials speak openly

Not every restriction is caused by hostility, but sometimes the record shows exactly how officials viewed someone’s faith. In Masterpiece Cakeshop, the Supreme Court said Colorado civil-rights commissioners had “endorsed the view that religious beliefs cannot legitimately be carried into the public sphere or commercial domain.” One commissioner compared using religion to justify harm to slavery and the Holocaust(!), calling it “one of the most despicable pieces of rhetoric that people can use.” The Court did not create a blanket exemption from nondiscrimination laws, instead it found that the state had not treated the baker’s religious objection with the neutrality required by the Constitution.

In Everett, Washington, students who came back from voluntary, off-campus Bible classes were told to keep their religious materials in sealed envelopes inside their backpacks. Only after a judge granted the families temporary relief did the district settle. Its settlement statement apologized for the difficulty its actions caused and for comments board members had made about the families at public meetings: “We recognize that these statements negatively affected the exercise of your faith.”

The Wisconsin graduate, the Everett students, and the Mississippi third-grader did not ask their schools to lead a prayer. Instead, they were told to leave out a thank-you, hide their materials, or take off a mask. That’s how “keep it private” works in real life.

“We recognize that these statements negatively affected the exercise of your faith.”

Why the danger goes beyond believers

If you do not share these beliefs, why should these restrictions matter to you? The same rule that lets one student say God helped her also lets another student say she does not believe in God. A community does not become more tolerant by teaching people that the safest thing to do with their beliefs is to hide them.

Brian Grim and Roger Finke’s research across nearly 200 countries found that government control of religion was the strongest sign of religious persecution. This goes against the common idea that restrictions keep the peace. More government control led to more persecution. No one is saying a Wisconsin graduation slideshow is the same as violent persecution in other countries. The point is that limiting religious differences is not the same as learning to live with them.

People also do a lot of good because of their faith: volunteering, giving, and creating charities, schools, and other organizations that serve people who may not share their beliefs. Brian and Melissa Grim’s 2016 study estimated that religion’s annual value to the U.S. economy is about $1.2 trillion, using a middle estimate. This is a broad measure, not a share of GDP or a prediction of what restrictions would cost. Another study of 173 countries found a link between religious freedom and economic growth using 2011 data. Religious freedom does not have to justify itself with money. The main point is that when we talk as if faith only belongs in a house of worship, we can miss how much it already shapes service to others.

What people are trying to remove

Some campaigns are pretty darn clear about what they want. In Carlsbad, California, the city council voted 4–1 against an open invocation policy and decided to remove the invocation slot. In another case about chaplains praying “in Jesus’ name,” the Freedom From Religion Foundation asked the city to end its sponsored chaplaincies altogether. Other people focus on a particular faith or its legal protections, for example Oklahoma voters passed an amendment to stop courts from considering Sharia law, but a federal court blocked it before it took effect.

Equal freedom also means taking seriously the families who object when states like Louisiana, Texas, or Arkansas require the Ten Commandments to be displayed in public-school classrooms. These rules have been challenged in court. No matter your view on the legal arguments, the difference is clear: when a student quotes Scripture, she speaks for herself. When the state chooses a religious text for every classroom, it acts with public authority. Supporting the first does not mean you have to support the second.

The irony of Christmas

Let’s talk about Christmas, a Christian holiday that celebrates the birth of Jesus Christ. In 2025, Gallup reported that 88% of Americans still celebrated it. Most people still exchanged gifts, just as they did in 2010, but fewer went to a Christmas service.

Now imagine someone saying to you, “If you don’t believe in Jesus Christ, you have less of a right to celebrate Christmas.” Sit with that. Who has the right to say that to you? Nobody. So why are we more comfortable with the reverse—with suggesting that the people who celebrate Christmas as a Christian holiday ought to leave the Christianity out when they talk about it in public?

In 2017 the Archdiocese of Washington tried to buy ad space on public buses for a message showing shepherds under a starry sky, with the words “Find the Perfect Gift” and a church website. Two different judges allowed secular Christmas ads but turned down this one because of its policy against ads promoting or opposing religion. The courts didn’t require the ad to run, though two Supreme Court justices called the rejection viewpoint discrimination. You could use Christmas to sell products, but not to say what Christmas celebrates.

What’s changing, and what isn’t

In 2006, 46% of Americans told Pew that houses of worship should stay out of political matters instead of speaking on social and political issues. By 2026, that number had grown to 66%. The surveys were done differently and opinions changed over time, but the difference stands out. In a shorter span, the share of people who said they’d rather avoid talking about religion when someone disagrees went from 33% in 2019 to 41% in 2024. These numbers don’t show support for banning speech. Instead, they show how willing Americans are to hear it.

This doesn’t mean people are necessarily turning against religion; in fact in 2026, 55% still saw religion’s influence as positive. The evidence shows a specific change: people are less interested in religious institutions speaking about public issues, but there is no steady increase in hostility toward faith.

What Hollywood brings into our homes

When the show 7th Heaven ended in 2007, it marked the end of a type of show: a family drama where religion was a normal part of life. The Camdens weren’t perfect, they faced the same family problems as everyone else. Watching the show felt like spending an evening with a minister’s family, not being told that the minister’s family was the problem. Later shows could do this intermittently. In Young Sheldon, for example, a boy who doesn’t believe in God still takes his mother’s crisis of faith seriously. He doesn’t need to share her beliefs to care about what they mean to her.

Now consider how Netflix promotes their new show The Body: “Catholic guilt, unholy desires and ghostly visions.” The creator calls the show “faith-positive, but system-critical,” and a Catholic school is fair game for a horror story. Notice what the pitch assumes will interest us: Catholicism as a source of guilt and fear. The real question isn’t whether Netflix should tell this story, it’s whether television also sees the ordinary believer—the person whose faith helps her grieve, help a neighbor, or get through a tough week—as someone we’d want to spend time with.

Viewers notice these stereotypes. In a HarrisX survey with the Faith & Media Initiative, 69% of U.S. respondents said TV and film keep religious stereotypes going. USC Annenberg researchers checked what actually appears on screen: in 100 popular U.S. films, only 1.1% of speaking characters were Muslim. In the larger international sample, about a third of Muslim characters committed violence, and more than half were victims of it. Neither study says TV has become more hostile since 7th Heaven. But together, they show this concern is more than just nostalgia: viewers see stereotypes, and researchers have shown how rarely some believers get to be shown as regular people.

Why people stay quiet

American Atheists put up billboards telling people to “Dump the myth” or skip church because they were “too old for fairy tales.” On ABC’s The View, Joy Behar joked that hearing from Jesus sounded like mental illness, and later apologized. These examples show ridicule and narrow portrayals, but they don’t prove that contempt for faith has steadily increased, and mocking religion is not the same as banning it.

But a more telling question is what people do when they expect a negative reaction. U.S. workplace researchers asked if people hid their religious beliefs at work because they worried about what others would think. The results: 51% of Hindus, 29% of Muslims, 19% of Jews, 13% of Catholics, and 9% of evangelical Protestants said they did. Researchers also found that nonreligious people sometimes hid their views in very religious workplaces.

A Muslim business owner explained why she avoided visibly identifying her faith: “I don’t want to be a target of anything.” People don’t need an official rule to get the message.

Is our religious freedom under threat?

Think back to the graduation slideshow. The district apologized, and the student’s challenge exposed the unequal treatment, but future graduating classes could not submit written messages anymore. Now consider the worker who stays quiet about her faith to avoid being singled out. One person spoke up and was told to leave the words out. The other chose not to speak at all because it felt safer.

Court victories are important. Apologies are important too. But neither one removes the pressure that led to the conflict in the first place. The real problem isn’t that every challenged rule will win in court. It’s that people may start to believe that using their guaranteed rights means risking their job, their spot in a program, or a fight with an institution they should be able to trust.

Religious freedom brings balance to competing philosophies. It promotes expressions of belief, hope, and peace. Religion inspires people to help others. Freedom of religion acts as a unifying and rallying force for shaping values and morality as well. The good of religion, its reach, and the daily acts of love which religion inspires only multiply when we protect the freedom to express and act on core beliefs. Nobody should have to profess a faith to belong in public life, and nobody should have to pretend they don’t have one.

Making Sense of COVID Part One      What if God Doesn’t Exist? The Case for Organized Religion

My Social/Political Hub

Leave a Comment